Chatham-Kent police chief Kirk Earley. (Photo courtesy of the Chatham-Kent Police Service)
Chatham

CK police defend officers involved in botched murder investigation

The Chatham-Kent Police Service is standing by the officers who investigated a Chatham murder in 2022.

David Thomas had his first degree murder charge dismissed on Thursday after a ruling that his rights were violated and some evidence collected by Chatham-Kent (CK) police was inadmissible.

Thomas was accused of killing his daughter, Bayli Sellars, in a Chatham house fire over four years ago.

The Crown said there was no reasonable prospect of conviction, adding it will be appealing the decision and seeking a new trial.

In a statement on Friday morning, CK police said they are confident that the officers acted in accordance with their lawful duties and responsibilities.

CK police noted they won't comment any further because the matter is before the courts.

The appeal will determine whether the evidence in question should be admissible at trial, said police.

"It is important to recognize that the appeal process exists specifically to review legal rulings and ensure that significant questions of law are properly considered through the judicial system," added police. "The Chatham-Kent Police Service remains committed to supporting the judicial process and working collaboratively with our justice partners as the case proceeds through the legal system."

CK police also said their thoughts remain with the victim's family and loved ones during this difficult time.

"The Chatham-Kent Police Service remains committed to supporting the family through the judicial process and to seeking justice through the lawful processes established by our courts," police said.

According to law, a decision on the appeal must be made within a year.

Read More Local Stories

Photo by Zuzana Cizikova from Pexels.

Scoreboard, Nov. 13

The Toronto Maple Leafs suffered another at-home loss, falling to Minnesota 5-2 on Thursday.